Verdict
Of course it's a great idea to release "Blue Christmas" on a single. But it's still a mystery to me why RCA Victor thought it was a good idea to couple the Christmas classic with a children's song.
(C) RCA Victor
The ultimate site about the king of the analogue age
On November 3, 1964 RCA Victor released "Blue Christmas" / "Wooden Heart". Billboard listed it on their "Christmas Chart" for four weeks where it peaked at number one. This might sound impressive, but in total the single sold no more than 200,000 units which can be translated to 37.5 million streams. In the present "Blue Christmas" is one of the most requested Elvis tunes on Spotify, clocking in at half a billion streams! In late December 2024 the song even returned to Billboards "Top100 Singles Chart" and peaked at number 36!
The single is not available on the streaming platforms. "Blue Christmas" can be heared on the album "Elvis' Christmas Album" (1958) and "Wooden Heart" was released by RCA Victor on the soundtrack "G.I. Blues" (1960). In 2016 the complete Presley catalogue was restored and remastered by Vic Anesini for a boxed set of 60 compact discs called "The Album Collection". Sony Music Entertainment provides the streaming platforms with the same versions of the individual tracks, albeit in 24 bit/90 khz flac. That means, if the platform of your choice supports high resolution audio, you can enjoy the songs in the same quality Sony used to scan and master them. On Spotify, which has a market share of approximately 30% and is the only platform that publishes streaming figures, "Blue Christmas" accumulates 500 million streams, "Wooden Heart" clocks in at 20 million. The Xmas song belongs to the 10 most requested Presley tunes on Spotify. However, it's quite amazing that drivel like "Wooden Heart" is able to generate so many streams.
The cover was designed with a promo photo for "Roustabout" and, well, a wooden heart. Of course "Elvis' Christmas Album" (1957) and the soundtrack to "G.I. Blues" (1960) were mentioned. The sleeve claims that both songs had been released on a 45 by popular request, but I guess RCA Victor simply wanted some airplay on the radio to boost the sales of these records.
Blue Christmas
The rock'n'roll king put this one on tape within three takes on September 5, 1957. The song was written by Bill Hayes and Jay Johnson, the first recorded version was done by Doye O'Dell. It finally got popular by cover versions of Ernest Tubb, Hogo Winterhalter & His Orchestra and Russ Morgan & His Orchestra.
Wooden HeartIn 1827 Friedrich Silcher adapted the German folk song "Muss I Denn, Muss I Denn Zum Staedtele Hinaus", 133 years later Fred Wise, Ben Weisman, Kay Twomey and Bert Kaempfert turned it into "Wooden Heart". Elvis recorded it on April 28, 1960 within four takes. Strangely though the writers didn't use the original German lyrics, but created new ones. They give the impression to have been translated with a mediocre software (just like my homepage). In Europe, Asia and South Africa RCA Victor released "Wooden Heart" on a single and sold more than 2 million copies in Germany alone! However, in the US the label stuck to the release on the album and left the number one hit to Joe Dowell.
Of course it's a great idea to release "Blue Christmas" on a single. But it's still a mystery to me why RCA Victor thought it was a good idea to couple the Christmas classic with a children's song.
(C) RCA Victor