www.elvis-presley.website

The ultimate site about the king of the analogue age

 

On January 4, 1957 RCA Victor released "Playing For Keeps" / "Too Much". Billboard started to list "Playing For Keeps" on their "Top 100" on February 2nd. It appeared nine times and peaked at number 34. The supposed b-side fared much better. "Too Much" entered the chart on January 26th at number 30, had a run of 17 weeks and became a number 2 hit. The song was also listed on the "Country & Western Chart" (#5) and the "Rhythm & Blues Chart" (#7). On the domestic market the single sold two million copies and was certified Platinum in 1992. Worldwide "Too Much" was the favorite, just the Brits preferred "Playing For Keeps" and made it a top 10 hit on the UK Charts (#6). But no matter which song was the incentive to buy, the people had to buy the same record. In total RCA Victor was able to sell 3 million copies, which equals 450 million paid streams. Today the situation is not much different. On Spotify "Playing For Keeps" barely accumulates 1.2 million streams while "Too Much" was requested more than 24 million times.

The picture on the sleeve was part of a series that had been shot for the cover of the album "Elvis". RCA also used photos from this session for the sleeves of the extended players "Stricktly Elvis" and "Just For You" as well as for the single "All Shook Up" / "That's When Your Heartaches Begin".

The single cannot be found on the streaming platforms. But "Playing For Keeps" is part of the album "For LP Fans Only" (1959) and "Too Much" can be heared on the long player "Elvis' Golden Records" (1958).

Playing For Keeps

The ballad was recorded on September 1, 1956 at Radio Recorders in Hollywood/California. Because Elvis was not able to produce a satisfactory take, the master was spliced of takes 7 and 18. "Playing For Keeps" was written by Stanley A. Kesler. In the song, the singer swears everlasting faithfulness to his loved one. I neither like the song nor Elvis' performance of it. RCA Victor released the track on "For LP Fans Only" (1959) and the boxed set "Worldwide 50 Gold Award Hits - Volume 1" (1970). 

Too Much

Here the singer is knowingly taken advantage of by his girlfriend, but he cannot leave her because he loves her so much. Somehow he doesn't seem to be affected by this issue at all, because the melody is peppy and there is not even a suggestion of sadness in Elvis' voice. "Too Much" was recorded on September 2, 1956 at Radio Recorders in Hollywood/California within 12 takes. To iron out the last few mistakes the king also produced two insert-takes. In the end the master was created of take 12 and insert-take 2. "Too Much" was not an original song, but a cover version. It had been written by Lee Rosenberg and Leonard Weinman and recorded by Bernie Hardison in 1954. Elvis' performance was released on the album "Elvis' Golden Records" (1958), the extended player "A Touch Of Gold - Volume 3" (1960) and the boxed set "Worldwide 50 Gold Award Hits - Volume 1" (1970).

 

Verdict

Even though the a-side is very weak, the supposed bonus "Too Much" is such a great song, that this release gets a five star rating anyway. It's a classic.

 (C) RCA Victor